- with readers working within the Pharmaceuticals & BioTech industries
- within Media, Telecoms, IT and Entertainment topic(s)
In the rapidly evolving field of AI-assisted patent drafting, it is easy to become mesmerized by tools that promise to generate a 30-page patent application at the click of a button. But as German and European Patent Attorney Bastian Best compellingly argues in his YouTube video, "The 30-Page Trap," this approach is fraught with peril. This review examines his crucial insights and recommends his video as essential viewing for any legal or technical professional engaged in creating intellectual property.
The Video's Main Purpose
Best's primary purpose is to issue a stark warning against the dangers of what he calls "outsourced reasoning." When we allow a "one-click robot" to do our work, we risk becoming "intellectual tourists" in our own inventions—merely validating a machine's statistical predictions rather than engaging in deep, critical thought. The video's core mission is to advocate for a paradigm shift: using AI not as a replacement for human intellect, but as a "tool for thought" that elevates our own reasoning. Bastian Best has developed a SaaS product for that purpose, the Claim Drafter.
Key Themes and Unique Insights
The video's argument is built on several powerful themes. Best identifies three key psychological risks of over-relying on automated drafting:
- Satisficing: The tendency to accept an AI-generated output that is merely "good enough" rather than strategically optimal.
- The "Filled Page" Problem: The hesitation to critique or substantially alter a polished-looking document that AI has already created.
- Mechanized Convergence: The propensity of AI to gravitate toward average, homogenous ideas, potentially watering down an invention's novelty.
What makes Best's analysis unique and central to his argument is the solution he presents and demonstrates. He advocates for an AI assistant designed on three principles: Material Engagement (forcing the user to get their hands dirty), Productive Resistance (challenging the user's assumptions), and Scaffolding Metacognition (handling rote tasks to free up mental space for strategic thinking). His live demo of a "claim drafter" for a smart dozing system perfectly illustrates this. The AI doesn't just write; it asks clarifying questions about the protection strategy, the infringer, and the technical USP, forcing a structured, thoughtful dialogue.
Context and Assessment
Best successfully makes his case by contrasting the superficial efficiency of a "one-click robot" with the profound, long-term value of a collaborative AI partner. He argues that the goal should not be mere efficiency, but better thinking, with efficiency as a welcome byproduct.
I fully endorse this philosophy. The danger of producing AI-generated "slop" is real, and it leads to weak patents that fail under scrutiny. The interactive, Socratic method Best champions is precisely the right approach to ensure the inventor's and attorney's intent is deeply embedded in the final work product.
This "tool for thought" approach is not just a concept; it is being implemented in the market. For those inspired by Best's vision, a similar tool is now available: especially for professionals and enterprises requiring a more robust and secure solution, our Microsoft Copilot Invention Collector Agent represents an improved and further developed version of this methodology. It operates entirely within your Microsoft 365 tenant, ensuring your confidential data never leaves your secure environment. You can find more information on our landing pages Microsoft Invention Harvesting Copilot (German version) and Microsoft Invention Harvesting Copilot (English version).
Recommendation: Why You Should Watch This Video
Bastian Best's video is more than just a commentary on a new technology; it is a vital call to action to preserve the human element—the "ghost in the patent"—in a digitized world. For patent attorneys, inventors, and legal tech professionals, watching this video is a crucial investment of your time. It will equip you to avoid the "30-Page Trap" and instead leverage AI to produce higher-quality, more defensible patents.
Watch the full video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oeHJ7zYXc6Q
IP Lawyer Tools by Martin Schweiger
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.
